Bruce Lipton Video
Recently I uploaded a video to facebook featuring Brue Lipton. In this video he is discussing the effect of our beliefs on our physical world and our physical selves.
This is an excpetionally interesting thought provoking video which you can find here.
http://www.2011tappingworldsummit.com/VideoSeries/?p=8
After posting this video I got a pointed and well conceived comment from Kevin. I felt I owed a respectable answer to his comment but, the reply would not fit in the limit for facebook comments. So I've posted it here instead.
If you're interested in energy medicine, energy healing or quatum physics, EFT or related subjects, you may find my post to be of interest. I've posted my reply below. In it I address some of the basic concepts on which many related fields of energy work lay.
Marvin Double Hi Kevin and thanks for taking time to post your very well constructed and thought provoking comment. You are of course correct that this video does not clarify the points Bruce Lipton makes. In fact, as you noted he is somewhat vague in offering anything in the way of actual proof, which is unfortunate. The examples he does point to don't really illustrate the essential argument well. In fact this is a very complicated subject which crosses the threshold of more than one aspect of human existence and is both physical and non-physical in nature.It is entirely true that when one has a headache, as a simple example, ASA may take away the pain. There are numerous such examples of how at the primary physical level drugs work to relive suffering or prevent disease. Polio, Small Pox, and Measles are some examples of how medicine has been used to successfully prevent illness. There is no argument from me that medicine is effective and often necessary in addressing disease, especially in critical or life threatening situations. I was saved from death from pneumonia at the age of 5 by penicillin. The question Lipton poses is simply this, "why was I so sick at 5 so as to need such dramatic medical intervention to prevent my death? Other children, when exposed to the same virus that made me so very ill, would have recovered with out the extraordinary medical assistance needed to keep me alive. Lipton is saying something fundamental about the reason why this should be so. In essence he's stating that, something in my energetic make-up made me susceptible to being ill. My immune system, being a reflection of my bio-energetic self was in some way compromised and unable to fight off the virus. As a result I needed outside help in the form of a drug which made it possible for my immune system to kill the virus so I could again become well. The illustrations Lipton uses are intended only to help us understand that we each have within us capabilities to heal ourselves which are often suppressed. We can however, though specific techniques evoke these capabilities to heal ourselves in ways which may in fact seem miraculous. Such capabilities are already well documented and can be scientifically validated. Such noteworthy examples are already available in studies comparing such things as the benefits of meditation on various medical conditions. However there is more here than is made visible by meditative techniques alone.Lipton does not unfortunately talk here about the fact that so called non-medical treatments are already the subject of scientific investigation and have been for some time. The famous or infamous placebo effect being one such element of such study. It is remarkable to consider that someone could be cured of a serious disease by the power of belief alone, yet this does happen. When it does, science is unable to offer an explanation that fits within current understanding or physical laws or theories. We are left with very non-scientific words like will-power, or spontaneous remission or worse still miracle. None of these offer a truly satisfactory answer to those natural questions which rise up when we are faced with something which seems beyond understanding. The explanation which Lipton offers is one which steps outside the strictly physical world. He is stating that, our thoughts have the ability to effect matter. In the case of healing, it is as simple as saying what we believe is as important to the outcome of our treatment as is any drug. This is the so called Mind-Body Effect. Hypnosis is one technique which has demonstrated the remarkable capacity of of the mind to, with property direction, overcome pain, even offering a non-drug anaesthetic like state during surgery. Such seemingly impossible things have been demonstrated under controlled conditions and validated beyond dispute for many years. Hypnosis is acknowledged as working via the sub-conscious mind through a process which is not yet entirely understood. It is only one of various techniques which address the subconscious and perhaps not the most effective. Not all drugs work on all people. There is a high degree of variability in how effective or ineffective any drug might be across the population in general. Such differences are not sometimes easily explained without entering into the realm of why we are different as individuals. Such is also true for things like hypnosis or another other technique to address our subconscious minds. There is a high degree of variability between individuals which can make it difficult to predict what will be effective in any given person. Some people will find ASA works to relieve a headache, while for others, relieve requires a different medicine. Such variability can be difficult to explain in groups of people with very similar physical traits. Scientists and doctors all generally accept that one such variable factor is something which is not physical but rather lies within a persons beliefs. Simply put, for some pain is intolerable and any pain, seems unbearable. For them the effect of ASA may be overcome by anxiety that causes their body to react in such as way as to override the analgesic effect. For others, even a single ASA tablet would be more than enough to mediate or eliminate their pain. The only difference between those 2 individuals is what they believe. One finds pain to be a terrible trail, something to be feared and fought. The other accepts that a headache is just a part of life, nothing of much concern that will go away in time. Scaled up to something more serious, like cancer, one can see how such a difference in belief might effect the outcome of treatment. Taken to yet another level, once might then see how, such a difference in beliefs might in fact make one more likely to become ill or to be healthy. If indeed we accept that the mind can and does effect the body then it is not hard to understand how such could be possible.The big issue with medicine, or the pharmaceutical industry is that the Mind/Body Effect can't be quantified, while the effects of drugs can. The unfortunate result of this is to create a division between those seeking a purely physical way of treating disease and a method that addresses less understood, but no less powerful, connections between mind and body.The gaps and divisions between these 2 apparently opposing points of view is however closing. There is recognition on both sides of the divide that each is valid and useful.It seems pretty obvious that at the age of 5 no one could have expected that I could cure myself of pneumonia by changing my beliefs. Dramatic medical intervention saved my life. Today as a Reiki practitioner I can look back with an understanding of the roll my own energies played in allowing me to become sick. With an adult understanding that everything is energy, I now know that the virus that made me sick could only take hold if my immune system could not fight it off. Another child, with a different energy profile, exposed to the same virus would not have become so ill as did I. There is a very old saying "change your thoughts and change yourself, change yourself and change the world." Such I think is appropriate for the point I am making here. At the heart of this matter is the so called mystery of life. When it comes down to it, there is a point to be made which is the essence of all discussions. What is the force which gives us life? What is it that animates us and allows us to breathe, keeps our hearts beating and our minds to function? This mysterious life force is the thing which is the origin of all the stuff of which universe and all life in it is made. This thing which is in fact beyond our capacity is measure scientifically but can be seen and felt, is the great unknown in the middle of the debate. We know it exists, and yet can't prove it. We can see the by-product of such existence in those things which we can touch and measure. We can now tear apart atoms and peer into the fundamental sub-atomic energies which create the glue that holds together the bits and pieces. But still, there is that pressing question that hangs in the air, unanswered. What is the governing force of creation? The argument being made is simply this. Everything is energy, even our thoughts. At very basic level, our thoughts interact with and effect the physical world and in some way change it. Evidence that this happens can be found in various examples, which is illustrated by people doing things which generally believed to be impossible. Such impossible things are accomplished by virtue of the adoption of a belief. The assumption being that, a belief, being the energy contained in thought can manifest an effect in the physical world. Such a construct challenges us to look at what we actually do believe. Is for example the entire world, even the larger universe a reflection of collective thought? Have we the capacity, as some suggest, to create from our mutual thoughts the reality in which we live? Is our existence a manifestation of energy driven by the so called collective unconscious? Do we as individuals have more control over our physical well being as well as the nature and progress of our lives than we know by changing our beliefs? It is clear to me, through my own personal experience that there is something more to me than just the physical me I see in the mirror (perhaps lucky for me). For me this idea of me as energy is not far removed from the concept of me as a soul. These are in fact the same basic idea simply expressed using different terms. The idea that I am an accumulation of energies, which I will call thoughts, is also easily accepted. The idea that I am a physical manifestation of these thoughts, also makes sense to me. It is then not much of an effort for me to see how changing those thoughts which as energy created the physical me, might also create my strengths or weaknesses, both physically and mentally. By extension then, by reflecting on and revising certain thoughts (beliefs) I can effect me at a physical level.From that perspective, if indeed those core energies of thought or beliefs can be accessed via the sub-conscience, it would be possible to, in a sense reprogram how I function on a physical level. This would give me the capacity to overcome disease etc from within rather than requiring external assistance. The debate on all this can go on from this point forward for quite some time. There are of course numerous examples of things that are clearly very wrong such a birth defects, or good people to which bad things happen. It's easy to get into the morass of right and wrong, good and bad. There is an obvious potential to lapse into some kind of religious argument as to what it all means. Such moralistic or judgemental aspects of the debate are not important for me. Here at least I confine myself to an attempt to explain the premise on which the debate comes to rest. That premise most simply stated is that, we have a capacity to change our physical world and our physical selves by changing our beliefs. It is my belief that we in fact do have this ability. I also believe this it is for each individual to come to their own decision on this point. This is a matter of personal choice and the courage to be open to exploration. Each much find their own way.


